1. Discuss the way Tub is presented in the opening scene. Does your assessment
of his character change in the later scenes?
2. How does the cold, hostile environment in the story relate to its meaning?
3. Which is the most sympathetic of the three characters? The story deals, in
part, with the power struggle among the characters. Which character is the
most powerful? Do the balance of power and alliances between the characters
shift as the story proceeds?
4. How do the physical descriptions of the characters help us to understand them?
For example, how is Tub's obesity relevant to his character?
5. The second half of the story includes some surprising twists and turns. How
are these more meaningful and substantial than the random plot twists one
might find in a purely commercial work of fiction?
6. What other elements of the story suggest that this is a serious, literary work
rather than merely an entertaining yarn about three hapless hunters?
7. What is the purpose of the scene in which Frank and Tub stop at the tavern
for food and coffee, leaving the wounded Kenny in the back of the truck?
During their conversation, Frank analyzes his own character and expresses
remorse. Are his insights and remorse genuine? Why or why not?
8. The final plot twist comes in the last two sentences of the story. Here the
narrator speaks directly to the reader, giving us information the characters
don't know. How is this an appropriate conclusion to the story? What final
statement is being made about the characters?